Apprenticeship ROI: Tracing the $1.47 Return-per-Dollar Claim

A mentor passes a combination wrench handle-first to an apprentice.

By the editors at Reliable. Last updated November 21, 2026.

Apprenticeship Return per Dollar at a Glance

Figure Source Who was measured What the dollar counts Time span What to know
$1.44 per $1 (44.3% ROI) Department of Labor evaluation by Urban Institute, Abt Associates, and Upjohn Institute researchers, 2022 68 U.S. employers nominated by grantees, surveyed in 2020 Estimated median total benefit per $1 of employer cost Apprenticeship plus 5 years Median estimated net loss of $4,951 per apprentice on direct benefits alone
$1.40 to $1.90 per $1 Review by Kevin Hollenbeck, released by the Department of Labor on April 30, 2026 Published studies, mostly U.S. Benefit per $1 in the estimates the author rates most rigorous Varies by study Includes the 68-employer study underlying $1.44
$1.47 per $1 Canadian Apprenticeship Forum, June 2009 1,013 usable employer surveys in 16 Canadian trades Estimated revenue from the apprentice's work per $1 of cost Apprenticeship only, usually 4 years Average of trade ratios from 0.55 to 1.97; undiscounted
$1.48 per $1 JFF, July 2020 Three modeled cases from six sponsors studied, one 18-month manufacturing apprenticeship Estimated benefits per $1 of cost 18-month apprenticeship term Returns of 26%, 46%, and 72%; JFF says the results have limited generalizability
$27.68 per $1 Mathematica for the Department of Labor, 2012 Participants who enrolled in 2000 and 2001, five-state average Projected tax revenue per $1 of government cost 36 years from enrollment Employer costs excluded; the nine-year figure is $13.34
About 8%, 40%+, and 50%+ Department of Commerce with Case Western Reserve University, November 2016 Two companies among 13 businesses and intermediaries Modeled annual internal rate of return Varies by scenario Siemens about 8% or 50%+ by scenario; Dartmouth-Hitchcock 40%+ under its turnover assumption
$1.06 and $2.49 per $1 (Kansas) University of Kansas study dated May 2025 18 employers with complete data Median direct benefits per $1 of cost 1 and 5 years after completion Five-year model assumes a 3% discount rate and 10% annual separation
$1.74 per $1 (North Carolina) North Carolina Community College System and Department of Commerce, October 2020 42 programs with sufficient financial data Median value created per $1 invested At completion 86% had a positive return by completion
$1.32 per $1 (South Carolina) University of South Carolina study, results summary dated February 2024 165 firms surveyed, about 121 with an active adult program Estimated average return per $1, adult apprenticeships Fifth year after hire Brookings identifies the adult subgroup; youth programs $1.37 in year four

What the Return-per-Dollar Figures Say Today

At the median, the estimated benefit was $144.30 per $100 of employer cost in the Labor Department's 2022 evaluation of 68 employers participating in its American Apprenticeship Initiative. A separate review by economist Kevin Hollenbeck includes that evaluation and puts the most rigorous estimates at roughly $1.40 to $1.90 in benefits per employer dollar. The Labor Department released the paper on April 30, 2026.

Three older figures travel alongside. The $1.47 on many state, college, and federal pages was published by the Canadian Apprenticeship Forum. A $1.48 figure comes from a small study of one manufacturing apprenticeship. The $27 or $28 "public return" comes from an evaluation that left employers out of the calculation.

Some figures are original estimates. Others are rounded or restated versions of the same estimate. Each has its own numerator, denominator, and time span, and most of those labels have fallen off in circulation. The sections below put them back.

One point of vocabulary helps. "$1.44 back for every $1" is a benefit-cost ratio, and it includes the dollar that was spent. The gain is 44 cents, so the return on investment is 44%.

Where the $1.47 Comes From

The $1.47 was published in June 2009 by the Canadian Apprenticeship Forum in It Pays to Hire an Apprentice, a study funded by the Government of Canada. The report states the finding as an average benefit of $1.47 for every $1 an employer spends on apprenticeship training, a net return of $0.47.

The forum surveyed skilled trades employers across Canada from June to November 2008. Its model uses 1,013 usable surveys in 16 trades: 692 collected in 2008 and 321 from a 2006 pilot, of which 106 were updated by the employer and 215 were imputed.

Costs were apprentice wages and benefits (about 71% of the total), journeyperson supervision time (about 23%), wasted material and rework, training fees, and administration.

The benefit side was estimated revenue. The model took the hours an apprentice could be charged to customers and applied the employer's charge-out rate. Where employers of cooks and partspersons could supply no charge-out rate, the consultant applied a mark-up based on the journeyperson's wage.

Across the 16 trades, the average estimated cost was C$220,242 and the average estimated revenue was C$330,371, over an apprenticeship that usually ran four years. The $1.47 matches the simple average of the 16 trade ratios, with each trade weighted equally. The report applies no discount for timing.

Trade Cost per apprentice Estimated revenue per apprentice Net benefit Benefit per $1 Usable surveys
Heavy duty equipment mechanic $252,371 $497,636 $245,264 $1.97 66
Boilermaker $246,889 $473,696 $226,807 $1.92 5
Machinist $204,921 $383,877 $178,955 $1.87 48
Construction millwright and industrial mechanic $254,287 $403,272 $148,985 $1.59 30
Construction electrician $196,811 $293,048 $96,237 $1.49 166
Refrigeration and air conditioning mechanic $240,060 $344,601 $104,541 $1.44 118
Sheet metal worker $258,160 $322,022 $63,862 $1.25 51
Electrical power line and cable worker $336,770 $319,759 Loss of $17,011 $0.95 27
Hairstylist (two-year program) $77,096 $42,620 Loss of $34,476 $0.55 38
Average, all 16 trades $220,242 $330,371 $110,128 $1.47 1,013 total

Selected trades are shown, in Canadian dollars, and the last row covers all 16. Averaging the 16 trade ratios gives $1.47 per $1. Dividing average revenue by average cost gives about $1.50. The report rounds its dollar values, so some rows differ by $1 when subtracted.

The spread matters more than the average. Machinist and millwright apprentices returned well above $1.47, two trades fell below break-even, and the boilermaker ratio rests on five employers.

The model fits an employer that bills an apprentice's hours to a customer, as a contractor or repair shop does. An in-house maintenance team may have no external billing rate. It can estimate the cost of work that would otherwise go to contractors or overtime.

How a Canadian Average Became a U.S. Statistic

The Canadian report was cited by name in Washington. Ready to Work, a White House report issued in July 2014, gave employers' average return as $1.47 per $1 and footnoted the Canadian Apprenticeship Forum. A Labor Department training notice dated July 31, 2015 carried the same figure and the same citation.

Public-facing versions were looser. A White House post that the Labor Secretary coauthored on July 14, 2014 credited "studies from across the globe" and said the $1.47 came back as increased productivity, reduced waste, and greater front-line innovation. The Canadian researchers had estimated revenue from apprentice work and treated waste as a cost.

The department's April 21, 2016 fact sheet credited "international studies" without naming them, and a September 21, 2016 release said only "studies indicate." The documents show how much of the original attribution survived from one federal publication to the next.

The $1.47 remains in use as of November 2026. A Department of Energy workforce page gives it as the average employer return on registered apprenticeship programs and links the phrase to the Department of Labor's 2022 study, which reports $1.44. The Maryland Department of Labor's employer page says U.S. employers get $1.47 back for every $1 and lists the U.S. Department of Labor as its source.

Where the $1.44 Comes From

The $1.44 is the estimated median total benefit per $1 of employer cost in the Department of Labor's evaluation of the American Apprenticeship Initiative, a grant program launched in October 2015. Daniel Kuehn and colleagues at the Urban Institute, Abt Associates, and the W.E. Upjohn Institute published the employer study in 2022.

The sample was 68 employers that hired apprentices with support from the grants. Grantees nominated them, 100 were contacted, and the survey ran from March to October 2020. About a third of the programs were in manufacturing occupations.

The 68 employers described programs covering 2,854 apprentices. For the detailed calculations, each employer answered about one reference apprentice who had completed the program. Employers estimated that apprentice's productivity as a percentage of a fully qualified worker's. The first year after completion informed the estimate for the four years that followed.

The model adjusts training costs and output for apprentices who leave. After graduation it reduces direct gains as graduates leave and assumes the indirect benefits continue.

Costs were dominated by the apprentice's pay and benefits, with a median of $52,530 and a mean of $87,369 for an apprentice who completed. Lost mentor productivity averaged $11,010 per apprentice, classroom instruction $4,488, and registration $1,217. The researchers subtracted subsidies employers reported receiving from grant recipients.

Benefits came in two kinds. Direct benefits counted the value of the apprentice's work and the cost the employer avoided by not having to hire or promote another worker into the job. The researchers tested three ways of valuing apprentice productivity: low, medium, and high.

Indirect benefits were ten items such as reduced turnover, a stronger pipeline of skilled workers, less overtime, and less downtime. Employers rated each one as a percentage of the apprentice's productivity gain.

The results under the medium assumption:

  • Median return with direct and indirect benefits: 44.3%, or $144.30 per $100. The low and high assumptions give 39.4% and 91.4%.

  • Middle half of modeled employer returns: from a 7.4% loss to a 120.7% gain.

  • Annualized median return: 6.3%.

  • Median net benefit per apprentice with direct and indirect benefits: $17,862. Of the 68 employers, 46 (68%) at least broke even within five years of completion.

  • Median net benefit per apprentice on direct benefits alone: a loss of $4,951. On that basis, 44.1% of employers at least broke even.

  • At completion: 38.2% of employers had at least broken even counting indirect benefits, and 13.2% on direct benefits alone.

The two measures use different bases. Net dollar benefits are in 2020 dollars discounted at 3% a year. The 44.3% return is calculated from 2020-dollar estimates with no discount applied.

Indirect benefits decide the result. For 16 of the 68 employers, they alone moved the return from negative to positive. Those values are employer judgments about turnover, pipeline, and culture, scaled to an estimate of the apprentice's productivity.

Three breakdowns matter for plants:

  • Occupation. The 23 employers reporting apprenticeships in advanced manufacturing occupations had the highest median net benefit with indirect benefits, $100,106 per apprentice, and a median loss of $13,213 without them.

  • Program length. The 16 programs longer than 36 months showed a median loss of $56,283 on direct benefits, a gain of $8,277 with indirect benefits, and an annualized return of 1.2%.

  • Employer size. Employers with fewer than 100 full-time equivalent employees had a median net benefit of $38,612 with indirect benefits. Those with more than 500 had a median loss of $282.

The authors state the limits plainly. The sample does not represent all registered apprenticeship employers, many programs were new, and only 24 of the 68 were designed to last more than two years. A four-year maintenance or millwright apprenticeship sits in the study's smallest group, where the estimated return was thinnest.

The $1.40 to $1.90 Range

Hollenbeck's review puts the most rigorous estimates at roughly $1.40 to $1.90 in benefits per employer dollar. The Labor Department's Chief Evaluation Office released the paper on April 30, 2026 and lists its citation year as 2024. A department notice dated September 8, 2026 repeats the range and cites the paper.

Hollenbeck judges the "most comprehensive and rigorous" estimates to fall between 40% and 90% in net return. His table of studies includes the 2022 American Apprenticeship Initiative evaluation, which he coauthored and rates as the most rigorous and complete U.S. estimate so far. The review does not identify the studies that set each endpoint. The 2022 evaluation estimated median returns of 39.4%, 44.3%, and 91.4% under its low, medium, and high productivity assumptions.

The review adds context to the $1.44 and draws on some of the same evidence, so the two belong together as overlapping findings. Hollenbeck also cautions that low response rates and self-selection likely tilt the estimates upward, and that the studies use different methods and time frames.

The $27 or $28 Public Return

The public-return claim says every $1 invested in apprenticeship returns $27 or $28 to taxpayers. It traces to the cost-benefit chapter of Mathematica's 2012 evaluation of registered apprenticeship in 10 states, written for the Department of Labor.

Across five of those states, Mathematica projected $19,875 in additional federal, state, and local taxes per participant over the 36 years after enrollment, against $718 in government costs. Its table reports $27.68 in taxes per government dollar, or about $28. The amounts are adjusted for inflation and discounted to 2000 dollars, and participants include people who left before completing.

Adding lower spending on unemployment insurance, food stamps, and welfare, with the related administrative savings, raises the government's total benefit to $25,748, or $35.86 per $1. The study's text gives the two ratios as "more than $27" and more than $35.

The $718 has two parts: $131 for the federal and state apprenticeship agencies and $587 for community college instruction. Employer spending appears nowhere in it. The authors excluded sponsors and employers for lack of cost and benefit data.

The authors also note that all of the benefit could be due to private investment. They test a case in which government spending accounts for 5% of the productivity gain.

The time span matters too. Over the first nine years after enrollment, the study's medium-term window, the tax return was $13.34 per $1. The $27.68 extends the earnings gap across 36 years for people who enrolled in 2000 and 2001.

Causation is a further caution. The authors write that their design does not conclusively identify the effect of apprenticeship on earnings, and the baseline treats the whole earnings difference as caused by the program. On a separate measure, career net social benefit, assuming half the gain is causal lowers the estimate from $124,057 to $61,596 per participant.

Retellings have loosened the wording. In a column dated May 29, 2015, "Building A Strong Workforce," a U.S. senator described $27 as the return on every federal dollar spent on apprenticeship training, crediting the Labor Secretary. Mathematica's $718 includes state agency and community college costs, and its tax gain counts all levels of government.

In House testimony on June 24, 2026, a Jobs for the Future witness put the public return at $28 per $1 invested in apprenticeships and tied it to higher wages and lower social costs. The original figure of about $28 counts tax receipts alone.

An employer's training dollar and a government program dollar pay for different things. The two studies use different participants, years, and costs. Adding the ratios would give a number with no consistent denominator.

Where the $1.48 Comes From, and How the Numbers Drift

The $1.48 comes from JFF's July 2020 study of the Industrial Manufacturing Technician apprenticeship, an 18-month, 3,000-hour program for production workers. JFF studied six sponsors, and three supplied enough data to estimate a return. Their estimated returns were 26%, 46%, and 72%, an average of 48%, or $1.48 in benefits per $1 of cost.

Two businesses supplied their own data. For the third case, JFF used union contract wages and a typical local contractor billing rate to estimate what a hypothetical apprentice could return. That case produced the highest of the three estimates, 72%. JFF states that the results have limited generalizability.

Four patterns show up when these figures are repeated:

  • The country drops off. The July 2014 White House report cited the Canadian study by name. A White House post that same month referred broadly to international research. Maryland's employer page presents $1.47 as a U.S. figure.

  • Numbers swap sources. A federal page prints $1.47 beside a link to the $1.44 study. An Apprenticeship Illinois handout prints $1.48 as a "USDOL national average." Where the handout's figure came from is unverified.

  • The ratio becomes the return. A benefit of $1.44 on $1 of cost is a 44% net return. Written testimony from Apprenticeships for America to the House Small Business Committee on February 24, 2026 used "144% return on investment" and gave no source for that percentage.

  • The denominator disappears. $28 per government dollar becomes $28 for every dollar invested in apprenticeship.

What Holds Up Across the Studies

The studies disagree on how often employers recover their costs during training. Under the federal study's medium productivity assumption, 13.2% of employers at least broke even by completion on direct benefits alone. In North Carolina, 86% of the 42 programs with sufficient financial data showed a positive return by the end of an average apprenticeship. Differences in the employers, costs, and valuation methods limit the comparison.

A Brookings review published on January 26, 2026 concluded that aggregate ROI estimates offer limited value to a prospective employer and can convey "false precision." Its summary table sets the federal study beside three state studies.

In Kansas, 18 employers supplied complete data for a University of Kansas study dated May 2025. Under its medium productivity assumption, the median employer was projected to receive $1.06 in direct benefits per $1 one year after completion and $2.49 after five, a 149% net return. The five-year model assumes a 3% discount rate and 10% annual separation. The state's July 9, 2025 announcement gives the five-year return as 246%.

North Carolina's October 2020 survey found a median gain of $0.74 on each $1 by completion, or $1.74 in total value, among 42 programs with sufficient financial data.

South Carolina's 2024 study, summarized in a state workforce meeting packet, surveyed 165 firms, about 121 of them with an active adult program. For adult apprenticeships, the estimated average was $1.32 per $1 by the fifth year after hire. Brookings's table identifies the adult subgroup.

Brookings draws on Swiss and German research for design advice. Employers that break even by the end of the program have recovered their training costs if a competitor hires the graduate after completion. Savings on outside hiring are a major part of the payoff, and wages, duration, time on productive work, and trainer quality all move the result.

Company-level evidence exists too. The Department of Commerce's 2016 report, written with Case Western Reserve University, examined 13 businesses and intermediaries. Across those that provided figures, per-apprentice costs ran from under $25,000 to $250,000, excluding start-up costs. Few of the firms had calculated a return themselves.

At Siemens in Charlotte, the researchers estimated an annual internal rate of return of about 8% from productivity and on-time gains, measured against low-experience machinists hired from outside. A second scenario reached 50% or more. It assumed enough repair demand to fill the plant's spare capacity and credited apprenticeship graduates with work the outside hires could not do.

For Dartmouth-Hitchcock's medical assistants, the estimated internal rate of return was at least 40% relative to paying providers overtime. That calculation assumed no grant funding and one fewer provider departure over four years. An annual internal rate of return and a multi-year benefit-cost ratio are different measures, so these percentages do not line up with the per-dollar figures above.

Calculate Your Own Apprenticeship ROI

Start with what the plant would do without the program, then count each benefit once against that alternative. If displaced contractor hours set the value of the apprentice's work, count those hours in one place only. For a cohort, include the costs and output of entrants who leave early.

  1. Total cost per apprentice: apprentice wages and benefits, plus mentor time (the added cost or the productive time lost), related instruction, registration and administration, and scrap and rework, less any grants or tax credits received.

  2. Total benefit per apprentice: the value of work produced during the program, plus the graduate's added value after completion, plus hiring cost avoided and any turnover or overtime savings you can document. For each year the graduate is expected to stay, compare the value of the graduate's output after wages and benefits with the corresponding amount for an outside hire, and count the difference.

  3. Benefit per $1: total benefit divided by total cost.

  4. ROI: total benefit minus total cost, divided by total cost.

Express retention as expected years worked, or as a separate probability for each year. A year-to-year retention rate compounds.

The worked example below is a four-year maintenance apprenticeship. Every input is an assumption for illustration, and a plant should replace each one with its own figure.

  • Costs. Wages and benefits average $60,000 a year across four years as the apprentice moves up the wage schedule ($240,000), plus mentor time ($36,000), related instruction ($12,000), registration and administration ($4,000), and scrap and rework ($3,000). Total: $295,000.

  • Work produced during the program. 40%, 60%, 80%, and 90% of a journey-level technician's output across the four years, valued at $95,000 a year. Total: $256,500.

  • After completion. The apprentice graduates and fills a vacancy, avoiding $20,000 in one-time recruiting cost. The graduate is expected to work four of the next five years. After allowing for each worker's pay and benefits, the graduate contributes $8,000 more per year than an outside hire would, or $32,000 in all. Total: $52,000.

Training costs exceed the value of the apprentice's four years of output by $38,500. Once the graduate fills the vacancy and the plant avoids $20,000 in recruiting costs, the remaining shortfall is $18,500.

Over nine years, assumed benefits reach $308,500 against $295,000 in costs: $1.05 per $1, an undiscounted gain of $13,500, or 4.6% in total. These are assumed inputs for one apprentice who completes.

Raising each training year's output share by 10 percentage points lifts the result to $1.17 per $1. Cutting expected post-training service to 2.5 years lowers it to $1.01, with the $20,000 recruiting saving held fixed.

The example counts no turnover or overtime savings. In the 2022 study, all ten indirect benefits together moved 16 of 68 employers from a loss to a gain.

How to Cite These Figures

Each line below keeps the label attached to the number.

  • $1.44: In a 2022 Department of Labor study, the median of 68 nominated employers had estimated total benefits of $1.44 per $1 of cost, counted through five years after the apprenticeship.

  • $1.47: A 2009 Canadian Apprenticeship Forum study estimated an average of $1.47 in revenue per $1 of cost across 16 trades in Canada.

  • $1.40 to $1.90: A review by Kevin Hollenbeck, released by the Department of Labor in 2026, puts the most rigorous employer estimates at $1.40 to $1.90 per $1.

  • $27 or $28: A 2012 Mathematica study for the Department of Labor projected $27.68 in career tax revenue per government dollar, about $28, averaged across five states.

How We Evaluated

Independent editorial analysis based on publicly available government data, peer-reviewed research, and the original pages behind widely quoted benchmarks.

Reliable does not sell scheduling software, staffing services, or consulting and has no commercial interest in routing readers toward any particular vendor. Reliable does not accept payment for rankings. Vendors may sponsor enhanced listings with additional detail, but editorial rankings are independent. Read our editorial policy.

We traced the employer and public-return figures to the reports that calculated them. We checked the Canadian trade tables, the federal studies, the Kansas and North Carolina reports, and South Carolina's published summary of its 2024 results. For each estimate, we compared the sample, costs, benefits, and time horizon with the wording used in public materials as they stood in November 2026.

Honest Limitations

  • No study here measures a random sample of U.S. employers. The 2022 study's employers were nominated by grantees, and its authors say the sample does not represent registered apprenticeship employers.

  • Benefits are estimates. Apprentice productivity is an employer's judgment against a qualified worker, post-program years are projected, and indirect benefits are employer ratings.

  • The Canadian figures are 2008 estimates that incorporate updated and imputed data from a 2006 pilot, in Canadian dollars. The model credits billable revenue, which an in-house maintenance team may not have.

  • The public-return figure rests on a 36-year projection for people who enrolled in 2000 and 2001. Its authors caution against reading the earnings gap as fully causal.

  • State samples are small: 18 employers in Kansas and 42 programs in North Carolina. The South Carolina figure comes from the state program's published summary of the 2024 study, and Brookings identifies the adult subgroup.

  • The U.S. evidence cited here does not establish a national return for a four-year, in-house industrial maintenance apprenticeship. The worked example uses assumed inputs and predicts nothing about any plant.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the ROI of a registered apprenticeship for employers?

In the Department of Labor's 2022 study of 68 employers, the estimated median return was 44.3%, or $1.44 in benefits per $1 of cost, counted through five years after the apprenticeship and including indirect benefits such as lower turnover. With the study's ten indirect benefits excluded, the estimated median net loss was $4,951 per apprentice. A 2026 review that includes this study puts the most rigorous estimates at 40% to 90%.

Where does the $1.47 return on apprenticeship come from?

It comes from the Canadian Apprenticeship Forum's June 2009 report, It Pays to Hire an Apprentice. The report averaged benefit-cost ratios for 16 Canadian trades from employer surveys, with estimated revenue from the apprentice's billable hours as the benefit. Ratios ran from $0.55 for hairstylists to $1.97 for heavy duty equipment mechanics. A July 2014 White House report and a July 2015 Labor Department notice both cited the Canadian study.

Is $1.44 per dollar the same as a 144% ROI?

No. $1.44 back per $1 is a benefit-cost ratio that includes the original dollar. The gain is 44 cents, so the ROI is 44%. In the 2022 study that return accrued over the apprenticeship plus five years, and the annualized median was 6.3%.

What is the $27 or $28 public return on apprenticeship?

It is projected tax revenue per $1 of government cost in Mathematica's 2012 study for the Department of Labor. Averaged across five states, the study projected $19,875 in added taxes over the 36 years after enrollment against $718 of agency and community college cost per participant, a ratio of $27.68. Employer spending is excluded. Over the first nine years the figure was $13.34.

How long does it take an employer to break even on an apprentice?

In the 68-employer federal study, 38.2% at least broke even by completion and 67.6% by five years after completion when indirect benefits were included. On direct benefits alone, the figures were 13.2% and 44.1%. Other samples differ: Kansas estimated 56% at break-even or better by completion, and North Carolina reported positive returns for 86% of its 42 programs with sufficient financial data.

Do manufacturing apprenticeships return more than the average?

In the 2022 federal sample, the 23 employers reporting apprenticeships in advanced manufacturing occupations had a median annualized return of 9.8% under the medium productivity assumption, compared with 6.3% across all 68. Their median net benefit was $100,106 per apprentice with indirect benefits and a loss of $13,213 on direct benefits alone. Canadian machinist and millwright apprenticeships showed estimated revenue of $1.87 and $1.59 per $1. These samples are too small to establish a national manufacturing premium.

Related Guides

Sources