The Cost of Federal Regulation per Manufacturing Employee

Estimated federal regulatory burden per manufacturing employee: $29,100 average, $50,100 at small manufacturers

By the editors at Reliable. Last updated November 20, 2026.

At a Glance

Figure Value Source Data date Scope Caveat
Regulatory burden per employee, all manufacturers $29,100 NAM study (Crain and Crain, 2023) 2022, in 2023 dollars All federal regulation; manufacturing employer firms Modeled sector burden allocated per employee; benefits not valued
Small manufacturers $50,100 NAM study (2023) 2022, in 2023 dollars Fewer than 50 employees $40,700 of it is environmental
Medium manufacturers $28,000 NAM study (2023) 2022, in 2023 dollars 50 to 99 employees Size-class average
Large manufacturers $24,800 NAM study (2023) 2022, in 2023 dollars 100 or more employees Size-class average
All business sectors in the study $12,800 NAM study (2023) 2022, in 2023 dollars Employer businesses across sectors Same method
Manufacturing sector total $349 billion NAM study (2023) 2022, in 2023 dollars $1.458 million per firm; 40% of payroll NAM rounds to $350 billion
Components per manufacturing employee Environmental $17,200; economic $10,400; safety and homeland security $1,000; tax $500 NAM study (2023) 2022, in 2023 dollars All manufacturers Economic share is forgone output
Prior edition, all manufacturers $19,564 NAM study (Crain and Crain, 2014) 2012, in 2014 dollars Small manufacturers $34,671 Different index and dollar year
EPA major rules, agency-estimated annual cost $45.4 billion to $54.7 billion OMB 2017 report, Table 1-1 Fiscal 2007 to 2016, in 2015 dollars 39 rules with benefits and costs monetized; benefits $194.3 billion to $687.0 billion Joint DOT and EPA rules tabulated separately
Compliance labor share of wage bill 1.34% to 3.33% Trebbi, Zhang, and Simkovic 2002 to 2014 Firms in the study sample; government and privately enforced industry rules Endpoints are conservative and broad task definitions
Pollution abatement operating costs and capital spending $20.7 billion operating; $5.9 billion capital Census Bureau PACE survey 2005 Manufacturing plants with 20 or more employees, excluding apparel Latest survey year; includes state, local, and voluntary abatement
Estimated net savings from fiscal 2025 federal actions $211.8 billion OIRA final accounting Fiscal 2025 Government-wide Present value as of 2024, including future years

The Headline Numbers

The estimated federal regulatory burden on U.S. manufacturers is $29,100 per employee per year, roughly 2.3 times the $12,800 estimated across all business sectors. Both figures come from The Cost of Federal Regulation to the U.S. Economy, Manufacturing and Small Business, which economists Nicole V. Crain and W. Mark Crain prepared for NAM.

Across the sector the study puts the burden at $349 billion a year, which NAM rounds to $350 billion. That is $1.458 million per manufacturing firm. The sector-wide estimate equals 40% of manufacturing payroll, compared with 19% of payroll across all the employer businesses studied.

The study used 239,607 manufacturing firms and 11,999,822 employees. Both counts match the Census Bureau's 2020 Statistics of U.S. Businesses, although the study labels its table 2021. The 2021 file shows 238,851 firms and 11,710,424 employees.

Trade at $8,500 per employee, services at $10,900, and health care at $5,800 sit well below manufacturing in the same study. Its residual category for all other industries comes closest, at $24,900.

The estimate measures 2022 and is stated in 2023 dollars. As of November 2026, NAM still cites its 2023 study for these figures. The 2026 Economic Report of the President restates the 2014 edition's all-firm estimate for 2012, at $13,000 per employee in 2024 dollars.

Why the Estimate Is Twice as High for Small Manufacturers

The study assigns $50,100 per employee to manufacturers with fewer than 50 employees, about twice the $24,800 at manufacturers with 100 or more. Firms with 50 to 99 employees sit at $28,000. At the small-firm rate, a 20-employee manufacturer comes to about $1 million a year.

Environmental rules drive the gap. The study assigns small manufacturers $40,700 per employee in environmental costs, against $15,200 at medium firms and $12,500 at large ones. The study estimates that a 1% increase in firm size goes with a 0.43% decrease in abatement cost per employee, an economies-of-scale effect.

Economic regulation runs the other way, at $7,600 per employee for small manufacturers and $11,000 for large ones. The study reassigns costs that small firms are exempt from to medium and large firms. The combined workplace safety and homeland security category ranges from $900 to $1,300 per employee, and tax compliance from $400 to $800.

A separate line of research finds a different shape. Francesco Trebbi, Miao Ben Zhang, and Michael Simkovic measured compliance work as a share of payroll in The Cost of Regulatory Compliance in the United States, published in The Review of Financial Studies in 2026. Across the industries studied, that share rises with firm size up to about 500 employees and then falls.

Midsize firms run about 47% above the smallest firms and 18% above the largest in that study. The authors report a less pronounced pattern in manufacturing.

What Is Inside the $29,100

Four categories make up the figure: environmental rules at $17,200 per employee (59%), economic regulation at $10,400 (36%), occupational safety and health and homeland security at $1,000 (3%), and tax compliance at $500 (2%). In sector dollars that is $206 billion, $125 billion, $12 billion, and $6 billion. The percentages are Reliable calculations from the study's table.

The environmental estimate starts with the prior study's baseline and adds later estimates, chiefly from federal agencies. The 2023 study draws on reports from the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) for 2012 through 2019 and agency regulatory impact analyses for 2020 through 2022. It puts the national total at $588 billion, assigns 65% to business, and assigns manufacturing 54% of that business share.

The economic estimate comes from a cross-country regression. The authors related GDP per capita to a regulatory index from the IMD World Competitiveness Ranking across 36 OECD countries from 2000 through 2022. Their model estimates how U.S. output could differ if the country scored closer to the highest-ranked countries. The study's allocation tables assign $125 billion of economic regulatory cost to manufacturing, or $10,400 per employee.

The study describes this lost output as an indirect cost of compliance. About a third of the $29,100 is therefore a share of forgone national output, which appears in no plant's ledger.

Two boundaries matter when quoting the number. The study measures costs only and makes no estimate of regulatory benefits. It also assigns each cost to whoever bears it first and does not model how much manufacturers pass on to customers.

The study also surveyed NAM members between July 20 and September 1, 2023, drawing 283 responses. Respondents reported an average of 14.2 full-time equivalents of in-house staff time on compliance: 2.6 at small firms, 2.0 at medium firms, and 23.0 at large ones.

The authors extrapolated those in-house labor costs by firm size to about $349 billion for the sector. That is close to the manufacturing allocation from their separate economy-wide model, although the two methods cover different costs. They also diverge by size: the labor extrapolation from the 2023 member survey alone is $72,765 per employee at small firms, above the $50,100 total-burden estimate.

In the same survey, 62% of respondents used outside advisers. One in five reported a cost from federal compliance activity in the prior 12 months, and the average among those firms was $669,100.

What Earlier Editions Estimated

The $29,100 is the latest figure in a series W. Mark Crain has authored or co-authored since 2001, first for the Small Business Administration's Office of Advocacy and since 2014 for NAM. The published dollar amounts rose across editions. The studies used different dollar years, methods, and definitions of a small firm.

Edition and sponsor Data year Dollar basis All manufacturers Small manufacturers Small-firm cutoff
Crain and Hopkins (2001), SBA Office of Advocacy 2000 2000 dollars $7,904 $16,920 Fewer than 20 employees
Crain (2005), SBA Office of Advocacy 2004 2004 dollars $10,175 $21,919 Fewer than 20 employees
Crain and Crain (2010), SBA Office of Advocacy 2008 2009 dollars $14,070 $28,316 Fewer than 20 employees
Crain and Crain (2014), NAM 2012 2014 dollars $19,564 $34,671 Fewer than 50 employees
Crain and Crain (2023), NAM 2022 2023 dollars $29,100 $50,100 Fewer than 50 employees

NAM states that its modeled sector total rose 26% after inflation, from $277 billion in 2012 to about $350 billion in 2022. The per-employee figures in the table are each in their own year's dollars. The small-firm cutoff moved from 20 employees to 50 with the 2014 edition.

Methods changed as well. The 2010 edition built its economic estimate on a World Bank index, the 2014 edition on World Economic Forum survey measures, and the 2023 edition on the IMD index. The Congressional Research Service (CRS) notes in Methods of Estimating the Total Cost of Federal Regulations that the updates used different methods and that comparisons across editions call for care.

What Other Sources Measure

Three other sources offer different views of compliance costs. OMB reports agency projections for selected rules, the Census Bureau surveyed plant spending on pollution abatement, and a study of occupational tasks estimates compliance labor as a share of payroll.

Federal agencies' own estimates are the first. OMB's 2017 Report to Congress on the Benefits and Costs of Federal Regulations covers major rules issued in fiscal 2007 through 2016. For 39 EPA rules with benefits and costs both monetized, it lists annualized costs of $45.4 billion to $54.7 billion and benefits of $194.3 billion to $687.0 billion, in 2015 dollars.

OMB listed four joint EPA and Transportation Department rules separately. EPA rules alone accounted for 55% to 64% of monetized costs in the ten-year comparison, and five OSHA rules had estimated annual costs of $0.4 billion to $0.5 billion. The comparison excludes non-major rules and rules issued before the ten-year window, so OMB says the totals for all rules in effect are likely to be significantly larger.

For 19 executive branch rules issued in fiscal 2023 with monetary estimates of both costs and benefits, OMB reported annual costs of $15 billion to $19 billion and annual benefits of $49 billion to $78 billion, in 2022 dollars.

The second measure is a plant survey. The Census Bureau's Pollution Abatement Costs and Expenditures: 2005 covered manufacturing plants with at least 20 employees and excluded apparel. It estimated $20.7 billion in operating costs, including $2.8 billion of depreciation, and $5.9 billion in capital expenditures.

Chemical manufacturing had the highest operating costs at $5.2 billion, followed by petroleum and coal products at $3.7 billion. The survey counted abatement done for federal, state, and local requirements and for voluntary reasons, and 2005 is the latest survey year.

The third measure is the payroll study. Trebbi, Zhang, and Simkovic estimated that compliance tasks took 1.34% of the average sampled firm's wage bill from 2002 through 2014 under a conservative definition and 3.33% under a broader one. The measure covers federal, state, local, and privately enforced industry rules.

Across all private establishments, the two definitions yield $103 billion and $239 billion in 2014. Among the three-digit industries in the authors' sample, chemical manufacturing ranked third by the average share of an establishment's payroll devoted to compliance, at 3.27%. Petroleum and coal products manufacturing ranked fourth, at 2.99%.

CRS has reviewed earlier editions of the Crain series. Its 2016 report observes that the index behind the 2014 economic estimate records executives' perceptions and that omitted variables could overstate regulation's effect. It adds that wealthier economies may themselves adopt more regulation and that the top-down and agency-based components could overlap.

Its 2011 analysis of the 2010 edition reports that an author of the World Bank index said the study had misinterpreted it. The Crains replied that they had used the index correctly.

What Has Changed Since 2022

The $29,100 is the study's estimate of the burden for 2022. It predates rules finalized in 2023 and 2024 and the federal rollback that began in 2025.

Executive Order 14192, signed January 31, 2025, directs agencies, unless prohibited by law, to identify at least ten existing regulations for repeal for each new one.

The Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs (OIRA) put net savings from fiscal 2025 actions at $211.8 billion in its Final Accounting for Fiscal Year 2025, stated as present value as of 2024. That total includes savings expected in later years. Before fiscal 2026 ended, OIRA's regulatory plan projected $1.5 trillion in savings from that year's actions. Neither figure gives an annual saving per manufacturing employee.

In a separate review of fiscal 2026, the American Action Forum identified 152 final rules that cited the executive order and carried quantified effects. The sample breaks down as 95 deregulatory, 15 regulatory, 19 exempt, and 23 not applicable. The forum calculated about $1.49 trillion in estimated net savings across the sample.

The forum attributed most of the estimated savings to three actions. The Transportation Department revised vehicle fuel-economy standards. EPA partially repealed carbon standards for fossil-fuel power plants and rescinded its 2009 greenhouse gas endangerment finding for motor vehicles along with the associated vehicle emission standards.

NAM received 220 responses to its Manufacturers' Outlook Survey for the third quarter of 2026. On the question about business challenges, 36.6% of respondents selected an unfavorable business climate, a category that names taxes and regulations as examples. It ranked eighth of 12 choices, behind raw material costs at 80.8% and health care and insurance costs at 72.3%.

Calculate Your Own

A plant can build its own figure from its ledger. The NAM survey's cost categories give a workable structure: in-house staff time, outside advisers, equipment bought to comply, the cost of running that equipment, and enforcement costs.

Compliance cost per employee = (in-house compliance labor + outside advisers + annualized compliance capital + compliance operations and maintenance + permits, fees, testing, and training + penalties and enforcement response) รท average headcount

Count each expense once, and include only the incremental cost attributable to compliance. Tag costs shared among federal, state, and local obligations separately. Report penalties and unusual enforcement costs apart from recurring costs, even when both go into the total.

In-house labor is the hours spent on compliance tasks times a loaded hourly labor cost. In NAM's second-quarter 2023 outlook survey, which is separate from the survey in the study, more than 63% of respondents reported over 2,000 hours a year on federal compliance, and more than 17% reported over 10,000.

Here is an illustration for a 150-employee manufacturer with one plant. Every input is assumed:

  • In-house labor: 6,000 hours at $55 loaded = $330,000

  • Outside advisers: $90,000

  • Annualized compliance capital: $180,000

  • Compliance operations and maintenance: $120,000

  • Permits, fees, testing, and training: $40,000

  • Penalties and enforcement response: $0

The total is $760,000, or about $5,070 per employee.

For scale, applying the study's rate for manufacturers with at least 100 employees to 150 workers gives $3.72 million. That rate includes an estimated $11,000 per employee in forgone economic output. The $760,000 example counts only the assumed plant expenses listed above.

The study assigns size classes by the employer's total workforce. A 40-person plant can belong to a company with thousands of employees. The step from the under-50 average to the 50-to-99 average therefore says little about the cost of hiring a 50th employee.

How We Evaluated

Independent editorial analysis based on publicly available government data, peer-reviewed research, and the original pages behind widely quoted benchmarks.

Reliable does not sell scheduling software, staffing services, or consulting and has no commercial interest in routing readers toward any particular vendor. Reliable does not accept payment for rankings. Vendors may sponsor enhanced listings with additional detail, but editorial rankings are independent. Read our editorial policy.

Figures were checked against their cited sources on November 20, 2026. Percentages and the worked example are labeled as Reliable calculations or assumptions.

Honest Limitations

  • NAM, a trade association that advocates on regulatory policy, commissioned the 2023 study behind the headline figures. The CRS critiques cited here address the 2010 and 2014 editions, and we found no CRS review of the 2023 edition.

  • The estimate is for 2022. It predates rules issued in 2023 and 2024 and the rollbacks of 2025 and 2026.

  • The study estimates the initial burden of federal regulation and excludes regulatory benefits. For economic regulation, it uses an index of each country's legal and regulatory framework.

  • About a third of the figure is forgone output from a cross-country regression. CRS calculated that a different benchmark country would have cut the 2010 edition's economic estimate by nearly two-thirds.

  • The comparisons cover different periods and groups. The 39-rule EPA comparison spans fiscal 2007 through 2016, and the fiscal 2023 OMB estimate covers 19 executive branch rules. The Census abatement survey covers 2005, and the payroll study covers the industries in its sample from 2002 through 2014.

  • The study's firm and employee counts match Census data for 2020, which the study labels 2021.

  • OIRA's fiscal 2025 total is a present value as of 2024, and its fiscal 2026 figure was a projection. Both cover actions across the federal government.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does federal regulation cost per manufacturing employee?

An estimated $29,100 per employee per year for the average U.S. manufacturer, against $12,800 across all business sectors studied. The estimate comes from a 2023 study commissioned by the National Association of Manufacturers and measures 2022 in 2023 dollars. NAM still cites it as of November 2026.

Why is the estimate higher for small manufacturers?

The study assigns $50,100 per employee to manufacturers with fewer than 50 employees, about twice the $24,800 at firms with 100 or more. Environmental rules explain the gap: $40,700 per employee at small manufacturers against $12,500 at large ones. The study attributes this to economies of scale in pollution abatement.

Is $29,100 what a manufacturer spends on compliance?

The figure estimates total economic burden, which is broader than compliance spending. About 36% of it is economic regulation, measured as national output the model treats as forgone. A plant's own spending depends on its processes, permits, and workforce, and the national estimate cannot establish how much that plant spends.

Who calculated the figure, and how has it been reviewed?

Economists Nicole V. Crain and W. Mark Crain prepared it for the National Association of Manufacturers, and earlier editions date to 2001. The Congressional Research Service reviewed the 2010 and 2014 editions. It raised concerns about the index behind the economic estimate, possible double counting, and the absence of benefits.

How much of the estimate comes from workplace safety rules?

The study reports occupational safety and health together with homeland security rules. That combined category comes to $1,000 per manufacturing employee, about 3% of the total, with $1,300 at small manufacturers and $900 at large ones. Environmental rules are the largest category at $17,200.

Has deregulation since 2025 lowered the cost?

As of November 2026, NAM still cites its estimate for 2022. The Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs put the present value of net savings from fiscal 2025 actions at $211.8 billion and projected $1.5 trillion for fiscal 2026 actions. Those government-wide figures do not establish how annual costs per manufacturing employee changed.

Related Guides

Sources

  1. National Association of Manufacturers: The Cost of Federal Regulation to the U.S. Economy, Manufacturing and Small Business (2023 study, 2022 data); executive summary of the 2014 edition (2012 data); Manufacturers' Outlook Survey, Third Quarter 2026; The Future Success of Small and Medium Manufacturers (2006, Tables 3 and 4 for the 2000 and 2004 figures, copy hosted by Columbia University); October 25, 2023 release (second-quarter 2023 survey hours)

  2. Congressional Research Service: Methods of Estimating the Total Cost of Federal Regulations (R44348, 2016); Analysis of an Estimate of the Total Costs of Federal Regulations (R41763, 2011)

  3. Office of Management and Budget: 2017 Report to Congress on the Benefits and Costs of Federal Regulations (final report, fiscal 2007 to 2016); Report to Congress on the Benefits and Costs of Federal Regulations, fiscal year 2023

  4. The Review of Financial Studies: The Cost of Regulatory Compliance in the United States (Trebbi, Zhang, and Simkovic, 2026); authors' manuscript (August 2025, industry table A.3)

  5. U.S. Census Bureau: Pollution Abatement Costs and Expenditures: 2005 (report MA200(05), copy hosted by EPA); 2020 Statistics of U.S. Businesses and 2021 Statistics of U.S. Businesses (firm and employment counts)

  6. American Action Forum: The Trump Administration's Regulatory Budget in FY 2026 and Beyond (October 7, 2026)

  7. Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs: Final Accounting for Fiscal Year 2025 under Executive Order 14192; Introduction to the 2026 Regulatory Plan